Angelo's - Evansville: Experience Exquisite Italian Dining

Garlic knots were awesome. My fettucine alfredo was great, but too high of a sauce to pasta ratio. Salad bowl arrived with a chip in it. I thought that was an outlier but then my entree plate also had a chip in it. Utensils were not provided until after salad had already been served. Mistakes were made on multiple orders at our table and had to be sent back to be corrected. Place was not busy at all at the time, so that was not an excuse for the confusion. Hostess was super nice and apologized, but it seemed like it was an ongoing situation that day as I also overheard apologies at a table across from ours.

We went to Angelo's on a Saturday evening for a date night. Where to begin? The atmosphere inside and out was divine. The food was out of this world. I had the chicken parmigiana with a house salad and rolls. My partner had the veal pepper. Both were incredibly tender and flavorful, with pasta cooked to a perfect al dente. We shared the crab cakes appetizer and it was definitely a highlight of the meal. Lightly breaded and smothered in a housemade cream pesto sauce with sun dried tomatoes over angel hair pasta. It was without a doubt one of the best dishes I have ever eaten. Homemade garlic rolls were perfect as was the salad dressing. Our service was incredible and Angelo was so kind and accommodating. One of the best people in America!

Had a large party for my cousins birthday last night. Booked the Gondola Room downstairs. The food was superb even did a custom dish for me that wasn’t on the menu! The 2 waitresses were even better! They took such great care of us the entire night! Also the owner even came down to wish my cousin a happy birthday annd gave her a bottle of wine. He wanted to make sure we were happy with everything. Love this place and the outstanding hospitality. Thank you all!

This place will blow your socks off best Italian food in evansville and it's not close

Delicious Italian food. Highly recommend the baked ziti, and if you can get a side of marinara sauce to dip the amazing garlic knots in, that's the pro move. Great staff and great food, will definitely be back.

Let me start with I have eaten alot of italian food, I lived in New York city for awhile. So my expectations are never to high in the area. We got 3 appetizers first stuffed mushrooms, they were not great, not much flavor at all couldn't taste or see the crab, and they used white button mushrooms. All the kids enjoyed the baked ravioli, and cheese sticks I didn't try them. Then salad and rolls came out, the salad was nothing special olive gardens salad is much better. The rolls or garlic knots were excellent, probably the best thing I ate. I got pasta carbonara it was ok, small portion. My wife got lasagna she wasn't to impressed. Our friends got eggplant parm and said it was OK it would have been better if it came with a pasta, and also the chicken corden blue to which they said was excellent. So overall it was so so, I have had better at small pizzerias in the north, but everyone's tastes are different so don't let my opinion sway your decision alot of people seem to like this place.

Angelo's is still the great place it's been for thirty years. Angelo still really cares and does whatever it takes to make sure you have a good meal. He makes a dish for me with no questions asked, which is not even on the menu. Enjoyed my birthday there with about fifteen friends and it was a great evening. Entwined next door is a great place to enjoy a drink before or after dinner as well.

Staff were nice and accommodating. Nice artwork and painting giving Italian atmosphere. I wish they were playing music that matches Italian atmosphere. The lighting could have been better. Clean bathrooms. Started with the house salad and bread -5 Salad had too much dressing on it. Bread was homemade and tasty but too much oil. Spaghetti was a 7 The pasta quality was average at best. The sauce was well balanced but seemed store brought. This meal cost $14. I believe the portion was decent for the cost. Stuffed mushrooms were a 6 They were not stuffed with real crab meat and I didn’t taste any ricotta cheese or bread crumb. The cheese was good that the mushrooms came in. Italian margarita was a 5 They were out of orange juice so I subbed pineapple juice and it did not hit. Dessert wine was a 9 Silk pie is just a chocolate cake. They were out of chocolate syrup. The texture was not our favorite - 7 Cheesecake - 7 It was a cheesecake lol not a fan of cherry sauce but not bad. Overall, Angelo’s was a 4 star. I would eat there again but maybe not dine in.